Brighton Pittsford Agency

Brighton Pittsford Agency is an independent insurance agency located at 30 Grove Street in the Village of Pittsford, NY. Founded in 1953, the agency has served the Pittsford and greater Rochester communities for over seven decades. As an independent firm, Brighton Pittsford Agency is not tied to any single insurance company — instead, the agency maintains relationships with more than 30 insurance carriers, allowing staff to match clients with coverage options across multiple providers.

The agency employs a team of roughly 14 professionals, including agents such as Robert Skuse, and operates as a family-oriented business focused on personal service rather than high-volume sales.

Brighton Pittsford Agency writes both personal and commercial lines of insurance. Their product mix includes:

• Auto, home, condo, and renters insurance
• Landlord and umbrella policies
• Jewelry and valuable-items coverage
• Wedding and event insurance
• Boat and watercraft coverage
• Classic and collector car insurance through Hagerty
• Business and commercial insurance
• Life insurance

Because the agency represents carriers like Travelers, Progressive, and Hagerty alongside many others, clients can compare quotes and coverage terms without visiting multiple offices.

Brighton Pittsford Agency is known for its longevity in the community — more than 70 years at the same Pittsford address — and for the independent-agency model that gives policyholders access to dozens of carriers through a single local office. The breadth of their product line, from standard homeowners policies to niche coverage like classic car and event insurance, reflects that multi-carrier approach. Their name itself signals roots in both the Brighton and Pittsford communities on the east side of Rochester.

The agency's office sits at 30 Grove Street in the Village of Pittsford, a walkable stretch near the Erie Canal towpath and the village's cluster of shops and restaurants along South Main Street. The village center is known for its historic preservation district, canal-side recreation, and tree-lined residential streets. Street parking is available along Grove Street, and the office is a short walk from the Four Corners intersection at the heart of the village. For clients coming from Brighton or the broader Rochester area, the agency is easily reached via Monroe Avenue or East Avenue heading east into Pittsford.