Forsythe has been at 66 Monroe Avenue since 1927 — nearly a century of fine jewelry in Pittsford, now in its fourth generation of family ownership. That kind of longevity in a single location isn't luck. It's what happens when a jeweler builds genuine trust with a community over decades.
The store is accredited by The American Gem Society, with two certified gemologists on staff and an in-house gem lab. The selection covers diamonds, colored gemstones, engagement rings, wedding bands, and estate jewelry — but what sets Forsythe apart is custom design. Bring an idea, a sketch, or just a feeling about what you want, and the team will work with you to build it. They also handle repairs, restoration, appraisal, and heirloom recreation. If a treasured piece is beyond repair, they can recreate it from scratch using similar techniques and materials.
Walk-ins are welcome. Appointments available for consultations, cleaning, shopping, and repairs. Open Monday through Saturday.
Recent Updates
Announcement
Forsythe Jewelers holiday sale, Thanksgiving hours, and repair deadline
Forsythe Jewelers at 66 Monroe Ave, Pittsford is holding a 20% off holiday sale December 3–5 (excludes estate pieces, special orders, custom designs, and select loose natural diamonds). Thanksgiving hours are Wednesday, November 25, 10am–3pm, with the store closed Thursday, November 26. Jewelry repairs dropped off by Monday, November 23 avoid holiday rush fees.
Special
Annual Holiday Sale: 20 percent off store-wide December 3-5
Forsythe Jewelers holds its Annual Holiday Sale December 3-5, 10am-5pm at 66 Monroe Ave., Pittsford. Shoppers receive 20% off throughout the store, with new pieces arriving in the case. Exclusions apply to estate pieces, special orders, custom designs, and select loose natural diamonds. For repairs without a rush charge, drop off by Monday, November 23.
Event
Forsythe Jewelers joins Candlelight Night December 1
Forsythe Jewelers at 66 Monroe Ave. participates in Pittsford's annual Candlelight Night on Tuesday, December 1, from 5pm to 8pm. Guests can warm up by the fire pit with hot cocoa and Tim Tams, with a sleigh photo op for children. Free parking available in their lot all evening.
Hours
Forsythe Jewelers shares Thanksgiving hours and new holiday pieces
The Monroe Avenue jeweler is bringing in new pieces for the holiday season and has posted adjusted Thanksgiving hours: open Wednesday, November 25 from 10am– 3pm and closed Thursday, November 26. The team also attended the American Gem Society Conclave in Orlando in September.
Announcement
Forsythe Jewelers holiday gift guide now available for the season
Forsythe Jewelers has launched its 2026 holiday gift guide, featuring hand-selected pieces for the season. The guide highlights curated jewelry and gift options available in-store and online at forsythejewelers.com.
Event
Forsythe Jewelers kicks off centennial with trunk show and appraisal event Oct 21
Forsythe Jewelers at 66 Monroe Ave., Pittsford is hosting two special events on Wednesday, October 21 to mark the start of its centennial year. The ASBA USA trunk show runs 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., featuring Tahitian and South Sea pearls, colored gems, and diamonds; charcuterie from Manna Boards will be served throughout the day. Heritage Appraisers, Inc. also returns by appointment from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. to provide up-to-date valuations for heirlooms and recent finds — call 585-586-5954 to schedule.
Event
Heritage Appraisers returns to Forsythe for Oct 21 appraisal event
Heritage Appraisers, Inc. returns to Forsythe Jewelers, 66 Monroe Ave., Pittsford, on Oct. 21, by appointment 10 a.m.–5 p.m. The event offers up-to-date valuations for heirlooms and recent finds. Call 585-586-5954 to schedule an appointment, or ask about dropping pieces off early.
Event
Forsythe Jewelers Annual Estate Jewelry Event returns Oct 8–10
Forsythe Jewelers is hosting their Annual Estate Jewelry Event at 66 Monroe Ave., Pittsford, October 8–10, 10am–5pm. An expanded selection of rare estate jewelry arrives courtesy of trusted estate partners, spanning many decades and styles, including bracelets, rings, earrings, and necklaces. Appointments can be booked online; walk-ins are also welcome.
Event
Forsythe Jewelers annual estate jewelry event Oct 8–10
Forsythe Jewelers, 66 Monroe Ave., Pittsford, is hosting its Annual Estate Jewelry Event Oct. 8–10, 10 a.m.–5 p.m. The event features an expanded selection of rare finds from trusted estate partners, spanning Art Deco elegance to bold contemporary design. Bracelets, rings, earrings, necklaces, and more will be on offer — the store notes these pieces "never linger long."
Event
Forsythe Jewelers Annual Estate Jewelry Buying Event returns August 4–6
For three days only, estate specialists McTeigue & Co. will be at Forsythe Jewelers (66 Monroe Ave., Pittsford) purchasing high-end estate jewelry, diamonds, and gemstones, 10am–5pm daily. Appointments are required — call or text 585-586-5954 to schedule.
Announcement
Forsythe Jewelers welcomes new team member Hailey
Forsythe Jewelers has welcomed Hailey as a new face behind the counter at their Pittsford location. The store invites customers to stop in and meet her.
Announcement
Forsythe Jewelers closed July 3 through 6 reopening July 7
Forsythe Jewelers will be closed from Friday, July 3 through Monday, July 6, 2026, and will reopen on Tuesday, July 7. Customers with repairs, custom pieces in progress, or upcoming occasions are encouraged to visit before the closure. The shop is also celebrating employee Susie's 70th birthday and running a Shop More Earn More summer rewards program.