The Leighton Agency

The Leighton Agency is an independent insurance agency located in Pittsford, NY, serving individuals and businesses across Monroe County and the Southern Tier since 1995. Chuck and Peggy Leighton founded the agency that year, and in August 2019 they transitioned ownership to Scott Hughes, who had worked at the firm for five years prior. Operating from the historic Pickle Factory building on Grove Street in the Village of Pittsford, the agency provides personal and commercial coverage through partnerships with more than 13 insurance carriers.

As an independent agency, The Leighton Agency writes policies across multiple carriers—including Erie Insurance and Travelers—allowing clients to compare coverage options and pricing. Their personal insurance lines include:

• Auto, home, and renters insurance
• Condo and landlord coverage
• Umbrella policies
• Motorcycle, watercraft, and RV insurance
• Jewelry and valuable-items coverage
• Wedding and event insurance

On the commercial side, the agency handles business owners policies, general liability, commercial umbrella coverage, and specialized programs for restaurants, contractors, property managers, fleet operations, and garage repair shops. The office is open Monday through Thursday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM and Friday from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM, with a 24/7 online client center available for policy management and claims reporting.

The Leighton Agency has maintained a continuous presence in Pittsford for over three decades, operating as a multi-carrier independent agency rather than a captive office tied to a single insurer. The staff holds combined industry experience exceeding 90 years and offers more than 75 distinct coverage types across personal and business lines. Their independent status allows them to place policies with whichever carrier best fits a client's risk profile and budget.

The agency occupies Suite 122B at 1 Grove Street in the Pickle Factory, a redeveloped historic building that traces its roots to Pittsford's days as an Erie Canal mill and manufacturing center. The location sits a short walk from the shops and restaurants of the Village of Pittsford's Main Street corridor. Free parking is available on-site at the Pickle Factory complex, making the office accessible for clients throughout the greater Rochester area.