
Pittsford Village Gateway Business District: Board Directs Staff to Draft Short-Term Rental Language After November 18 Workshop
The Short Version
- After a 35-minute workshop discussion on November 18, the board directed village attorney Jeff to draft code language permitting short-term rentals by special permit in the Pittsford Village Gateway Business District and Mixed-Use Erie Canal District.
- The proposed change would apply only to traditionally residential structures in both districts — commercial buildings would not qualify.
- A house adjacent to the N. Main / Schoen Place properties already operates as an Airbnb under LOR zoning, which currently allows short-term rentals while VGB does not.
- The district-wide code approach was chosen specifically to avoid the spot-zoning problem raised in August, when LOR rezoning for specific parcels was first discussed.
- No vote has been taken; any actual code change requires a formal amendment, public notice, and a board vote. The next Board of Trustees meeting is November 24, 2026.
The corner where North Main Street meets Schoen Place sits inside two different zoning districts — the Pittsford Village Gateway Business District on one side, the Mixed-Use Erie Canal District on the other. On Wednesday, November 18, the Board of Trustees spent roughly 35 minutes at a workshop asking whether the rules governing those two districts should change.
The clearest outcome: a trustee directed village attorney Jeff to draft language that would permit short-term rentals by special permit in both districts, limited to traditionally residential structures.
What the Board Decided at the November 18 Workshop
The November 18 workshop agenda listed item 2 as a review of permitted uses and boundaries within the VGB and Mixed-Use Erie Canal districts, with sub-item 2a focused specifically on the N. Main / Schoen Place intersection.
A trustee instructed attorney Jeff to review and draft language permitting short-term rental use by special permit in both districts — but only for traditionally residential structures. Commercial buildings would not qualify; the change targets structures that already have residential character.
The spot-zoning question from August came up directly. A trustee asked the village attorney whether adding STRs as a district-wide permitted use — rather than rezoning specific parcels — would constitute spot zoning. The district-wide approach is precisely the design: a code amendment that applies to every eligible structure in both zones avoids a change that benefits only one parcel.
One concrete detail grounded the conversation: a house adjacent to the subject properties already operates as an Airbnb under existing LOR (Limited Office Residential) zoning. The board discussed whether similarly situated structures in VGB and MUC should have the same option.
The August Backstory: How the N. Main / Schoen Place Corner Got Here

The August Backstory: How the N. Main / Schoen Place Corner Got Here
The November workshop grew from an August 11 board discussion that looked at whether the Limited Office Residential zone should expand to cover properties at 21, 25, 27, 32, and 36 N. Main Street. A trustee raised a spot-zoning concern: LOR allows short-term rentals, and VGB does not, so a rezoning to LOR would directly benefit one property owner.
The board sent the question to a workshop rather than advance a rezoning. By November 18, the frame had shifted. Instead of moving parcels into LOR, the board debated adding STRs as a permitted-by-special-permit use within the existing VGB and MUC zones. A district-wide code amendment applies to every eligible structure in both zones — not just the properties that triggered the August question.
What the Pittsford Village Gateway Business District Currently Allows
The VGB district's code establishes N. Main Street as a commercial gateway — a transitional zone between the northern neighborhoods and the Village Center at Schoen Place. The code names Pittsford Farms Dairy and Hawley House as anchors for the district's agrarian character.
Retail, bakeries, agricultural retail, and upper-floor residential apartments are permitted by right. Restaurants, boutique hotels, and inns require special use permits. Drive-through facilities are expressly prohibited. Short-term rentals are not currently listed among the permitted uses.
At the workshop, a trustee argued that short-term rentals would have lower impact on neighboring residents than several uses already permitted in the district. In the Mixed-Use Erie Canal District, STRs are already allowed on upper floors; the proposal would extend that to first-floor traditionally residential structures.
What Comes Next: A Code Amendment in Progress

What Comes Next: A Code Amendment in Progress
Wednesday's workshop was a discussion, not a vote. Village attorney Jeff's task is to review the code and draft language permitting STRs by special permit. Any actual change to permitted uses requires a formal amendment, public notice, and a board vote.
One trustee suggested the board could address rezoning questions and the use-change language simultaneously rather than in sequence.
The next Board of Trustees meeting is November 24, 2026. Residents with views on short-term rentals in these districts can bring them to the board before formal public notice is filed.
Content ID: MvsSq23IyveNT8nlxLumy2pd
See an error? Tell us.




5 Comments
Comment from Facebook
Is there a map available that outlines the districts being discussed? Is it only the addresses in the article that are being considered for STR status?
Nov 21, 2026 at 12:06 am
View on Facebook ↗Adam Stetzer
The two districts in play are the Village Gateway Business (VGB) district — essentially the N. Main Street corridor — and the Mixed-Use Erie Canal district around Schoen Place. The November 18 agenda described the workshop as a review of "permitted uses and boundaries" within both of those districts, with sub-item 2a focused specifically on the N. Main / Schoen Place intersection. The zoning code that defines those district boundaries is linked below. Basically - a hand full of historic houses at the busy intersection. I doubt anyone would really want to live there and they have been businesses for a long time. https://www.villageofpittsfordny.gov/vertical/sites/%7B20315D0E-D7FA-436A-B513-1586646A8CBA%7D/uploads/AgendaWorkshopBOT20261118.pdf
Nov 21, 2026 at 3:19 pm
View on Facebook ↗Comment from Facebook
I might be reading the code wrong, but it looks like the Village already allows up to two short-term rental permits in the Gateway District for rentals where the owner isn’t there. Are those two spots already taken? I’m just trying to understand what the proposed change would allow that the code doesn’t already, and how many more homes could qualify.
Nov 21, 2026 at 1:24 am
View on Facebook ↗Comment from Facebook
https://villageofpittsfordny.gov/vertical/sites/%7B20315D0E-D7FA-436A-B513-1586646A8CBA%7D/uploads/ZoningMapVOP20260514.pdf
Nov 21, 2026 at 6:51 am
View on Facebook ↗Comment from Facebook
The thought was to introduce additional flexibility for 2 short-term rentals in both the Village Gateway Business District and the Mixed-Use Erie Canal. Public discussion is warranted.
Nov 21, 2026 at 6:55 am
View on Facebook ↗Comments marked “from Facebook” were shared from our Facebook page. Commenter names are not published here — open the original thread to see them.
Share with the Community