Pittsford Village Chat
Adam Stetzer
Two Trustees Recap the November 10, 2026 Village of Pittsford Board Meeting
Pittsford Village Chat›Two Trustees Recap the November 10, 2026 Village of Pittsford Board Meeting
21 min read6 comments·Pittsford Village board meeting November 2026

Two Trustees Recap the November 10, 2026 Village of Pittsford Board Meeting

The Short Version

  • The Board voted 3–1 to hang Pittsford CommUNITY's holiday banner at the front of Village Hall, with Trustee Cove opposed; the motion sets no end date, so the banner stays up until a later vote.
  • The full Sutherland Street Phase 2 bid came in at $1,771,316.03, so the Board asked the DPW superintendent for an updated quote on a scaled-back Phase 2 and moved $72,000 from fund balance to cover Phase 1 costs.
  • A feasibility study for two accessible public restrooms at the south end of the Coal Tower lot on Schoen Place was approved, not to exceed $6,400.
  • Village counsel will draft a full property tax exemption for permanently and totally disabled veterans, following the Town's Local Law No. 3 of 2026.
  • Angus Irish Pub may stay open until 2 a.m. on November 26, the morning after Thanksgiving Eve, and David Jewett's holiday tree and wreath sales at 44 N. Main St. were approved; neither hearing drew public comment.
  • $19,740.23 in unpaid 2026 Village taxes on 10 properties goes to Monroe County for collection, and the next meeting is a 12:00 PM bill-pay session on Tuesday, November 24.

The November 10, 2026 Pittsford Village board meeting began at 6:00 PM on Tuesday at Village Hall, 21 North Main Street. The agenda and full meeting packet are posted on the Village website, and the meeting video is on the Village's YouTube channel. Trustee David Wilkes emailed his recap to neighbors on November 11, and Trustee Lisa Cove posted hers on Facebook. Excerpts from both appear below exactly as written, split by agenda item, along with the agenda items as filed and our analysis of the meeting's YouTube video transcript. Gray boxes show each item as filed with the Board; the first-color boxes are Trustee Wilkes's, the second-color boxes are Trustee Cove's, and the third-color boxes quote the meeting video.

The meeting video settles two points the trustees' recaps leave open: the banner motion that passed sets no end date for the display, and the Sutherland Street vote asked the contractor for an updated quote rather than approving a dollar amount.

Disclosure: Adam Stetzer serves as an alternate member of the Village of Pittsford Planning and Zoning Board of Appeals. The Angus Irish Pub item below involves a special permit under the Village zoning code. Renée Stetzer, the author's partner, founded and leads Walk Bike Pittsford, which advocates on active transportation matters including sidewalks and ADA accessibility.

Holiday Banner From Pittsford CommUNITY

The following is the item description as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

Pittsford CommUNITY Donation of outdoor banner for display from Diwali through Lunar New Year A donation has been offered to the Village of Pittsford for an outdoor banner recognizing Diwali and Lunar New Year. The banner would be displayed seasonally throught the two celebrations and is intended to reflect the Village's commitment to recognizing and celebrating the diversity of its community.
Trustee David Wilkes — Holiday Banner
  • This agenda item was supposed to be relatively quick and focused on

a banner donated from Pittsford CommUNITY recognizing various winter holidays, from Diwali, to Christmas, to New Year's, through Ramadan in early February 2027 and was intended to "reflect the Village's commitment to recognizing and celebrating the diversity of its community".

  • However...yeah, it didn't quite go that way:
  • Trustee Lisa Cove made multiple passionate speeches against the

banner, most of which focused on saying it violates the separation of church and state, and that we should leave this type of information to the schools to teach kids or put it at the library - She also noted that she has "spoken with residents who are not comfortable with this"

  • I reminded Trustee Cove that two years ago, the nation was railing

against "woke indoctrination of our children in public schools", yet we simultaneously now have a Department of Defense secretary who forces prayer down troops' throats at every turn, as if Christianity is the only religion in our nation, not to mention four states, Louisiana, Texas, Arkansas, and Alabama, where schools are forced to display the Ten Commandments...so, yeah, which one is it? Does a separation of church and state still exist, or has it simply morphed into "a separation of church and state when it's something that doesn't apply to me / I don't like"? - I also noted that I am sick of how "we always say the Village is so quaint and welcoming of all, yet we then do things like this", i.e., spend 45 minutes railing against the existential harm of a damn banner

  • Ultimately, the Board was forced to make two motions:

- The first motion was to simply accept the donation, of which the Board unanimously voted to accept - The second motion was to place the banner at Village Hall until a time in which a subsequent motion is made to remove it, of which Trustee Lisa Cove voted "NO", but I, along with the Mayor and Trustee Dave Marshall, voted "YES", so the motion passed

Trustee Lisa Cove — Banner Donation

Pittsford CommUNITY presented a donation of a banner representing many spiritual/religious beliefs from Diwali to Lunar New Year for donation and asked for it to hang at Village Hall at the front entrance from now until February 7th 2027.

This motion was approved by Mayor, Trustee Wilkes and Marshall. I voted against this for the following reasons;

I firmly believe in the separation between Church and State. As a governing body for ALL people, there is no need to place a religious/spiritual banner on the face of a municipal building.

Under the Town of Pittsford's operational policy, “outside public organizations, non-profits or private citizens cannot petition to hang their own flags or banners from the Town Hall building. We should be consistent in sharing that policy.

When a municipality chooses to hang banners or flags on public property is is considered government speech.

I admire the artistic quality and nature of the banner, it was well executed in inclusiveness of most believes (Atheists not respected), and I thanked the donor for thinking of the Village, wondering why this was not asked of the Town or the School District for which she is a resident of.

From the Meeting Video — Two Votes on the Banner

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 18:43. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

The donor's request (25:44): "So it's like February 7th, 8th depends on the moon." … "From now till February"

The first motion (39:37): "I make a motion to accept the donation with outdoor banner from this community"

The location, described at the table (42:04): "between my two windows in my office in the front of the building"

The second motion (42:14): "I'll make a motion that we install the banner at that location until some other motion is made to do something different." … "Put it up until the motion is to take it out."

What this means: The Board took two votes. The first accepted the donation; the roll call at 40:01 records Trustee Cove voting yes. The second placed the banner at the front of Village Hall, and the roll call at 43:56 records Trustee Cove as the one vote against. The motion as passed has no end date — the banner stays up until a later motion takes it down. The February 7, 2027 date in Trustee Cove's post reflects the donor's request, not the motion.

Monroe County Plan Forward Review

The following is the item description as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

Notice from Monroe County for a SEQR Action The Village has received a coordinated review request from Monroe County under the State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR) process and has been asked to provide comments on the proposed action. Village input is due to Monroe County by November 22. The Board is requested to review the referral and authorize submission of the Village's comments.
Trustee David Wilkes — Monroe County SEQR Notice
  • This agenda item was regarding a coordinated review request the

Village received from Monroe County under the State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR) process

  • As far as the actual proposed action by the county, it focused on

adopting and implementing "Plan Forward", a comprehensive plan for Monroe County meant to guide growth, investment, and decision-making over the next decade, of which sustainable development, protection of natural resources, and protection of water quality are major tenets

  • *The Board voted unanimously to notify the County as to receipt of

the review request and acceptance of the County as lead agency in the Type I SEQR process*

From the Meeting Video — Lead Agency Motion

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 59:11. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

From the table: "This is administrative"

The motion (1:00:39): "I make a motion um that we acknowledge Monroe County has a comp plan and they are serving as lead agency in said [SEQR] process."

Veterans Property Tax Exemption

The following is the item description as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

Review of Veterans Exemptions Provide by the Town Assessor The Village has received updated Veterans Exemption information from the Town Assessor for review by the Village Board. The Board is requested to review the information and take any action necessary.
Trustee David Wilkes — Veterans Exemption
  • This agenda item was regarding the updated Veterans Exemption law

the Village received from the Town Assessor

  • *The Board voted unanimously to direct the Village attorney to

draft similar legislation for the Village Code to provide a full exemption from taxation and other charges (special district, assessments, special levies, etc.) for permanently / totally disabled veterans*

From the Meeting Video — Veterans Exemption Motion

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 1:03:13. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

The motion (1:03:13): "I'll make a motion to direct village [counsel] to draft … alternative veterans property tax exemption language for the village"

Sutherland Street Phase 2

Sutherland Street Phase 2

Sutherland Street Phase 2

The following is the item description as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

Review of Sutherland Street Project Phase 2 The Village Board will review Phase 2 of the Sutherland Street Project, including updated cost estimates, project scope modifications, and potential alternatives. Discussion will focus on cost changes, project priorities, and the feasibility of alternate plans to inform future project decisions and budgeting.
Trustee David Wilkes — Sutherland Street Phase 2
  • This agenda item was regarding an updated proposal received from

our roadwork contractor for the Sutherland Phase II project, of which the price of entry has almost doubled (from an estimated $950K max, to over $1.7 million) due to inflation in the oil markets since the start of the Iran war

  • *After I had a bit of a "come-to-Jesus" moment last week with the

Village DPW Superintendent, it was determined the most prudent and fiscally responsibility path will be as follows: - Full mill and pave of Sutherland from Lincoln to Monroe (Est. @ $65K); - Reinforced asphalt on Sutherland from Lincoln to Monroe (final price will fluctuate with oil markets; however, current estimate is ~$35K); and - Replacement of blacktopped sidewalks with proper concrete sidewalks on strip of Sutherland south of Lincoln + ADA compliant curbing / ramps (Est. $50K) - Total estimate: ~$150K vs. $1.7M*

Trustee Lisa Cove — Sutherland Street Paving

The cost to complete as planned the Sutherland Street project next spring has significantly increased causing the board to vote on taking a more “maintenance approach” which will last for about 5 years. Instead of the proposed $1,771.316.02 coast we will spend about $150-200,000.

From the Meeting Video — What the Board Voted On

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 1:04:35. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

On sidewalk funding (1:04:35): "we have had received a $700,000 grant"

On the cost of the lower section (1:11:28): "let's say 100,000 to 200"

On lifespan (1:13:22): "getting another 5 to 10 years out of it."

The motion (1:21:56): "I'll make a motion uh that the superintendent contact villager for an updated quote on roadwork for … phase 2 modified."

A second motion (1:23:30): "I'll make a motion to transfer from fund balance 72,000 to cover the additional cost for the entire [Sutherland] road work."

What this means: Tuesday's Sutherland vote directed the DPW superintendent to get an updated quote from Villager, the Village's road contractor, for a modified Phase 2; it did not approve a dollar amount. The trustees' estimates differ (about $150K in Trustee Wilkes's recap, $150-200,000 in Trustee Cove's), and the range spoken at the table is quoted above. The second motion, which neither recap mentions, moved $72,000 from fund balance to cover Phase 1 costs that the original estimate did not include; the roll call at 1:23:42 records all four members voting yes.

Schoen Place Restroom

# Alt Text

Historic waterfront tower with American flag, riverside buildings, and gathering crowd on clear day.

Schoen Place Restroom

The following is the item description as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

[Schoen Place](/events/bike-safety-jamboree-at-schoen-place) Restroom Building The Village Board will review a proposal from the project architect for professional services related to the Schoen Place restroom building. Discussion will include the scope of services, associated costs, and consideration of next steps for the project.
Trustee David Wilkes — Schoen Place Restroom
  • This agenda item was regarding the Board's plan to improve the

current public bathroom situation on Schoen Place near the dock / replace the existing porta potty rentals

  • After combined discussions with the Village engineer and local

property owners, we have determine that the best location to construct a permanent restroom would be at the southern end of the Coal Tower public parking lot, across the street from the Rochester by Water ticket booth - The restrooms would be available for use by the public, as well as Rochester by Water, i.e., the operator of the Sam Patch Cruises on the canal

  • *The Board voted unanimously to approve Achitectura's proposal to

complete an architectural feasibility study, at a cost not to exceed $6,400, to provide the Village with detailed dimensional analysis necessary to complete any easement documentation with the land owner (essentially, the whole project can't truly start until this step is completed)*

Trustee Lisa Cove — Schoen Place Restrooms

Schoen Place Restrooms (at the edge of the Coal Tower parking lot)-

The board approved the first phase of the project for a feasibility study with the cost of $6400.00. We are moving forward to providing 2 handicap accessible with infant and adult changing stations and a small ice machine for authorized use.

From the Meeting Video — Restroom Design and Vote

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 1:26:41. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

On showers (1:26:41): "Short answer is no."

The reason given (1:26:43): "both of these bathrooms will be fully handicapped accessible with changing tables not only for infants but also for adults."

On the fee (1:33:47): "it cannot go over not to exceed."

The clerk's read-back (1:34:24): "[Trustee] Marshall made a motion to approve to accept the [Architectura] proposal to move forward with the plans and feasibility study for a bathroom down at [Schoen] Place and authorize the mayor to sign the contract."

New Resident Welcome Package

New Resident Welcome Package

New Resident Welcome Package

The following is the item description as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

Initative Update Re: New Village Resident Welcome Package • Update regarding completed timeline tasks for the new resident "welcome package / packet" initiative aimed at aiding in new resident acclimation. • Provide overview of all existing materials / cataloged documents from the "old" Village of Pittsford new resident packet. • Present initial draft of the proposed documents list for the "new" Village of Pittsford new resident welcome Packet.
Trustee David Wilkes — Welcome Package
  • This agenda item was an update re: the New Resident Welcome Package

initiative I introduced at the October 13, 2026 regular meeting

  • I notified the Board that my next step will be creating drafts of

each document I outlined in my draft of the proposed Village packet, at which point the next step would be further edits from responsible parties as applicable (see PDF page 37 for the updated timeline of milestones / responsible parties at each step)

Trustee Lisa Cove — Village Welcome Packet

Great work by Trustee Wilkes is in process, with details presented at the meeting.

Dignify New York Resolution

The following is the item description as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

Dignify New York The Village Board will consider adoption of the Dignity Not Discrimination Resolution, a statewide initiative of Dignity for All New York (DIGNITY-NY) that affirms the Village's commitment to fostering a welcoming, inclusive, and respectful community. The resolution expresses support for diversity, equity, and the fair treatment of all residents, visitors, and businesses within the Village.
Trustee David Wilkes — Dignify New York
  • This agenda item was added by the Mayor, and was a request to the

Board to consider adopting the "Dignity Not Discrimination Resolution", an initiative of Dignity for All New York (DIGNITY-NY) and the New York Conference of Mayors (NYCOM)

  • *The Board voted unanimously to adopted the resolution, albeit

modified / tailored to the Village vs. the stock form received*

From the Meeting Video — Dignity Resolution Motion

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 1:46:06. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

The motion (1:46:06): "I'll make a motion to uh accept the sample resolution provided by [NYCOM] um on dignity resolution. Make the appropriate modifications for our municipality and uh permit the mayor to sign."

What this means: The motion adopts the NYCOM sample resolution with changes for the Village and authorizes the mayor to sign it. The auto-captions of the roll call at 1:46:26 are incomplete and do not record every member's vote.

2026 Village Tax Surrender

The following is the item description as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

2026 Village Tax Surrender The Village Board will review and consider the 2026 Village Tax Surrender. The tax surrender identifies properties with unpaid Village taxes that are eligible for return to the County pursuant to applicable tax enforcement procedures and authorizes the submission of the required documentation.
Trustee David Wilkes — Tax Surrender
  • This agenda item was basically a review of the outstanding and

unpaid 2026 Village taxes that will now need to be turned over to the County for collection / applicable tax enforcement - There are 10 properties (tax tracts) in the Village that have failed to pay their Village taxes to date (see PDF page 46 of the meeting packet) - The total amount that went unpaid was $18,277.99, and due to being unpaid, the aggregate accumulated interest is $1,462.24, so a total of $19,740.23 is getting sent back to the County

  • I asked Dorothea whether this figure was high or low vs. previous

years, and she noted it was about one-third of the amount that went unpaid last year, so that's good to hear!

  • *The Board voted unanimously to approve the tax surrender amount, with

each Board member signing off on the documentation ahead of sending to the County*

From the Meeting Video — Tax Surrender

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 1:47:45. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

Comparing to last year (1:47:45): "I was looking at last year around 45."

The motion (1:47:59): "So I make a motion to surrender the unpaid village tax to the county."

Angus Irish Pub Thanksgiving Eve Hours

Angus Irish Pub Thanksgiving Eve Hours

Angus Irish Pub Thanksgiving Eve Hours

The following is the public hearing notice as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

Please note that a Public Hearing will be held before the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees on November 10, 2026, at 6:30 p.m. at 21 North Main Street, Pittsford, New York. The Board will consider a Special Permit application for 5 State Street (Angus Irish Pub) for an amendment to the current Special Permit for an update in operating hours for an event.
Trustee David Wilkes — Angus Pub Special Permit
  • This was a special permit request from Angus Pub (5 State Street)

to allow the pub to operate after midnight on Thanksgiving Eve until 2AM on Thanksgiving morning

  • *After opening the public hearing and receiving no comments, the

Board voted unanimously to approve the special permit, so, if adult beverages are your thing, enjoy a late pour on Thanksgiving Eve / Thanksgiving Morning!*

Trustee Lisa Cove — Angus Irish Pub Hours

Public Hearing’s below had no public comments.

2) Angus Irish Pub to extend hours on the evening before Thanksgiving, Wednesday, November 25th, 2026 from normal close at 10pm to allowing a 2am close, on this day only.

From the Meeting Video — The Amended Date

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 45:10. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

From the table (45:10): "except the change in the description to 2 am on November 26, not the 25th."

The motion after the hearing closed (49:26): "Make a motion to approve within"

What this means: As discussed at 45:10, the written application asked for 2 a.m. "on November 16th"; the Board approved it as 2 a.m. on November 26, the morning after Thanksgiving Eve. The roll call at 49:40 records all four members voting yes.

Holiday Market at 44 N. Main St.

The following is the public hearing notice as filed with the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees, November 10, 2026.

Please take notice that a Public Hearing will be held before the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees at a meeting on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, at 6:30 PM at the Village Hall, 21 North Main Street, Pittsford, NY, to consider an application for a short-term business permit to be located at 44 N. Main Street by David Jewett to conduct outdoor sales of Christmas trees, wreaths, and crafts.
Trustee David Wilkes — Holiday Market Permit
  • This was a request for a short term retail business permit for 44

N. Main Street for outdoor sales of Christmas trees, wreaths and crafts; this holiday market operation has been an annual tradition since at least 1995

  • *After opening the public hearing and receiving no comments, the

Board voted unanimously to approve the short term retail business permit, so, I'll see you at the tree stands soon!*

Trustee Lisa Cove — Holiday Market

Public Hearing’s below had no public comments.

1) David Jewett’s Christmas Tree Farm retail at Pittsford Dairy

From the Meeting Video — Holiday Market Vote

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions starting at 50:11. Brackets mark our corrections of misheard words; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

The applicant (50:11): "It's actually my 32nd or 33rd year."

The motion (54:03): A trustee moved to accept the short-term retail business permit, and the motion was restated "as presented."

Also at the Meeting

Also at the Meeting

Also at the Meeting

From the Meeting Video — Items Not in Either Trustee's Recap

From the Village's YouTube video, auto-generated captions. Brackets mark our corrections; ellipses mark trimmed filler.

Bills and financials. The Board approved the bills (1:48:52: "I'll make a motion to approve the bill pay as presented.") and the September and October financial reports (1:50:25).

Minutes. The October 13 minutes were approved (1:52:56).

Bike and e-bike law follow-up. Under member items at 1:53:14, a trustee asked about "the chapter 176 changes that we approve," the Board's direction to rewrite Local Law #3. The answer from the table: "Within the month." … "It's in the hopper."

Next Village of Pittsford Board Meetings

Next Village of Pittsford Board Meetings

Next Village of Pittsford Board Meetings

The following is the closing line of the Village of Pittsford Board of Trustees tentative agenda, November 10, 2026.

The next scheduled meeting is November 24, 2026 (bill pay) and December 8, 2026, and is subject to change without notice
Trustee David Wilkes — Next Meeting
  • The Board's next REGULAR meeting will be *Tuesday, November 24th

(FYI: this will be a BILL PAY meeting and starts at 12:00 PM)*

Trustee Lisa Cove — Next Meeting

The next “Bill pay only (in honor of the holiday) Trustee Board meeting will be Tuesday, November 24th 2026, 12pm.

Content ID: eEpXUoV4ZtyjjLVarcMgftpk

See an error? Tell us.

6 Comments

Comment from Facebook

David, you just voted for Dignify NY at the same meeting you’re writing about. I’d expect you to hold yourself to that standard in your public comments, too. You were wrong to reduce Lisa’s concerns to “railing against the existential harm of a damn banner.” She voted to accept the donation and raised a fair question about what the Village should display at Village Hall. You can disagree with her vote, but repeatedly making light of the people raising that concern goes against the commitment you just voted for. So I’ll ask the question your recap brushed off. What standard should the Village use the next time a group asks to hang a banner at Village Hall?

Nov 12, 2026 at 10:28 pm

View on Facebook ↗

Comment from Facebook

These proposals are a complete waste of time and energy, creating unnecessary division over issues that do absolutely nothing to improve the Village. Residents deserve a government focused on infrastructure, public safety, responsible spending, and maintaining the character of our community, not endless debates over symbolic gestures and political agendas. We have real issues that deserve attention. Turning every holiday or tradition into a controversy isn’t progress, and it certainly isn’t productive governance.

Nov 12, 2026 at 11:09 pm

View on Facebook ↗

Comment from Facebook

Pittsford = traffic problems

Nov 13, 2026 at 2:40 pm

View on Facebook ↗

Comment from Facebook

After reading Trustee Wilkes recap of this meeting and the most recent meeting, I'm glad I didn't vote for him. His campaign persona does not equate with his Trustee persona. The snarkiness of his tone in his meeting summary shows he is only receptive of ideas/comments that align with his own.

Nov 13, 2026 at 6:13 pm

View on Facebook ↗

Comment from Facebook

Trying to get through the village in a timely manner lately is very challenging. An important issue to discuss.

Nov 15, 2026 at 3:44 pm

View on Facebook ↗

Comment from Facebook

Instead of a big controversy over a banner no one will notice why not focus on number crunching and accurate infrastructure planning. I’m referring to the apparently bungled Sutherland Repaving Project. From what you’ve shown us the cost is escalating. I never fully understood why this was a two year project and was scheduled after the South Street repaving.

Nov 16, 2026 at 6:48 pm

View on Facebook ↗

Comments marked “from Facebook” were shared from our Facebook page. Commenter names are not published here — open the original thread to see them.

Share with the Community